Where Did All Our Freemasons Go?

by Midnight Freemasons Contributor
Todd E. Creason

I would venture a guess to say there's not one single Grand Lodge in the United States that isn't concerned about membership and Lodge attendance.  I know mine is.  In fact, very recently we have a new program called the Lodge Growth Program (LGP).  Secretaries such as myself are going to be required to keep track of how many members have attended our meetings in the past, average them out, then compare that to how many members are attending now . . . so we can track our growth (or lack thereof).  I don't see how that helps, but that's what we're doing.

What I expected to see in the growth program, and didn't, were a few thoughts about why our Lodge attendance might be low (things we may be doing wrong), and maybe a few suggestions about how to increase our Lodge participation (fresh new ideas).  Fortunately, I've got a few ideas of my own on this subject. I think I can explain why Lodge participation is such a problem in some Lodges.  I even have a few suggestions about what a Lodge experiencing these issues might do to improve in this area.

First of all, membership and Lodge participation are two very different things.  I know, I know--they are very often lumped together as one and the same, but they are most certainly not the same issue.  They are very different issues.  I'm sure I'll raise a few eyebrows by saying the far more serious problem isn't new membership--it's Lodge participation.  Lodge participation is really the problem you must solve--nearly every other issue your Lodge may be facing from financial issues to lack of new members most likely tracks back to your participation problem.

If you think I'm wrong, ask yourself a couple questions:  a.) how many members show up for your meetings?  How many members does your Lodge have?  I'll bet there is a dramatically larger percentage of members who don't attend than do.  Why is that?  b.)  How many of your newer members are attending?  How many have dropped off?  Why?  And now for the big question c.) What is the point of continuing to add new members to your rolls when you can't keep your old members or your brand new members involved?

I'll answer that last question for you--it's pointless to keep adding members to your roster until you figure out why you can't keep the ones you already have.  And I'll tell you the most common reason why Lodges challenged with these issues can't keep members involved.  It's quite simple actually.

Your meetings are boring!  Sorry to be so blunt, but it's true--right?  If you fix that problem, you'll go a long way to fixing all your problems.  As one of our Past Masters Denver Phelps so frequently says, "when they stop having fun, they'll stop coming."  It really isn't any more complicated than that.

I have six things you can do to improve your meetings--I have many more, but lets start with six.  Let me be clear--all these things are well within the by-laws in my jurisdiction, but if they aren't in your jurisdiction, don't feel you must send me an email to tell me it is against your rules.  Just don't break your rules, okay?  And certainly don't do it and say "Todd Creason said it was okay" because I get in enough trouble as it is in my own neck of the woods without you helping me.

But if these suggestions are within your by-laws and you try a few of these suggestions, I think you'll find your members will find much more enjoyment in your meeting than they do currently.  Those meetings may even become something the Brethren look forward to attending again.

And here they are:

Reading of the Minutes
The purpose of reading the minutes is to make sure your Secretary is doing his job correctly.  That he is recording things accurately and to ensure he hasn't left anything out or gotten anything wrong.  That's it.  I was in a meeting a few days ago where the Secretary spent fifteen minutes reading the minutes of a meeting that only lasted an hour the month before, right down to who sat in what chair.  And all fifteen Masons sitting in that room knew exactly what happened in that meeting the month before, because it was the same fifteen guys.  I sit through that every month, and it's dreadful every month.  I do the same thing as Secretary in my Lodge (although I only hit the highlights in my Lodge to try and keep it short).  But it's the 21st century folks.  Secretaries could print those minutes and have them available for preview prior to the meeting, or some Secretaries email the minutes of the meeting to members right after the meeting concludes.  The minutes should take minutes.

Treasurer's Reports
It took the Treasurer ten minutes to give his report in the same mind-numbing detail as the Secretary (right down to the check numbers).  Same thing.  Why not print the report and hand it to the members or email the report to them prior to the meeting?  Most members don't even listen to the details of how much the power bill was, and how much they charged to fix the vacuum sweeper.  They tune out.  They'll be more likely to look at the treasurer's report if it's printed than they are to listen to one.

In my neck of the woods, announcements often go on so long they actually refer to them at the end of our meetings as "the dreaded announcements."  You'll have three or four guys usually that will stand up in turn and list off one event after another after another after another--a degree here, a pancake breakfast there, a golf outing here.  We had a degree in my Lodge last week, and I glanced at the clock--announcements took a full fifteen minutes.  I'd been to four meetings/degrees in the last couple weeks and I'd heard the vast majority of those announcements over and over again.  And of course you have the guy that has to ask three times "what's that date again" or "what time did you say that starts again."  It's without question my least favorite part of any meeting, and I'm not alone there.  You'll see very few Masons writing things down during announcements.  

There are better ways to do announcements.  First of all, social media and the internet are far better means to get the word out about events.  In my area, we have a tool called "call-em-all" where I can call every member of my Lodge in about two minutes to remind them of an event using a recorded message.  One of the best ideas I've ever heard, however, is a little more old school.  One Lodge Secretary told me that for years, they've had no announcement (or very few) during their meetings.  He hangs an old fashioned desk blotter calendar on the wall of the Lodge--two months at a time with a box of markers next to it.  Members and visitors of the Lodge write their events on that calendar prior to the meeting or degree.  When, where, and what time.  They don't do announcements during the Lodge meeting.  He said many of the members just photograph that calendar on the wall with their phone when they're leaving and update their calendars at their leisure.

In my opinion, that's the best idea I've heard in years, and that Secretary is deserving of the highest Masonic honor that can be awarded a Lodge Secretary!  What a fantastic idea!

So Now What?
Lets say you do these three things.  You've cut down dramatically three areas that the vast majority of Masons dislike intensely.  And in my area, that's just saved a good forty minutes that we can now put to better uses.  Perhaps since we now have a little more time we could do one or two of the following.

Education Every Meeting
Education can be anything you want it to be.  My suggestion is to share inspired articles from the Midnight Freemasons blog (he says with a straight face) and then discuss it.  If you have a Lodge instructor or somebody good with ritual, you might have him go over a point in the ritual that everyone gets wrong.  Test your Masonic knowledge.  Have somebody put together some trivia questions and perhaps elected officers can compete against appointed officers.  Or maybe the Brethren could compete individually for a prize--like a copy of Famous American Freemasons for instance (another shameless plug)Whatever you decide to do, have fun with it.

Invite a Speaker
One of the best meetings I recall was one a few years ago.  We helped a young woman go on a trip to Germany as part of an exchange program.  She came and talked to the Lodge when she returned.  Our Lodge went to refreshment, we invited her in, and she gave an excellent talk about her adventures--she even brought the Lodge a gift.  It was a wonderful evening.  Speakers can be members of your Lodge, or somebody from the Shrine.  Perhaps a WWII vet with a great story to tell.  Got a local Masonic author, scholar or researcher--from experience I know they're very often more than happy to come and talk to your members for fifteen or twenty minutes.  The Midnight Freemasons individually are asked to do this all the time.

Topic For Discussion
One Master I spoke to said that each month he announces a topic of discussion for the following month.  Maybe it's about a historical event, or a famous Freemason, or the meaning of a certain symbol.  The Brethren have a month to think about it.  He tells me their discussions are extremely entertaining.  That's a great way to spark a little discussion in your lodge.  As a matter of fact, he says sometimes they announce the subject on their Facebook page and they get guests from other Lodges interested in taking part in that discussion.

I wrote in a piece some time back that sometimes Masons get so involved in the business of Masonry we forget why we became Masons to begin with--to learn, to serve, and to become better men.  Business is an important part of a meeting, but so is learning, discussion, and fellowship.  If you want established members to keep coming, and new members to get involved and stay involved, your Lodge has to engage them.  You have to give them something they'll look forward to.  They have to feel like they're getting value from that time they spend in the meeting, and the only thing dull meetings provide are reasons for Freemasons to stay home and watch the game.

If you can build a Lodge like that--they will come.  And they'll talk about it and invite their friends to join as wellA lack of petitions won't be your problem, scheduling all the degrees will be.  And that's a problem every Lodge would like to have. 

*Special thanks to my photographer--my daughter Katie.  Not bad for an eight-year-old, huh? 


Todd E. Creason, 33° is the Founder of the Midnight Freemasons blog and continues to be a regular contributor. He is also the author of the From Labor to Refreshment blog, where he posts on a regular schedule on topics relating to Freemasonry.  He is the author of several books and novels, including the Famous American Freemasons series. He is a Past Master of Ogden Lodge No. 754 (IL), and currently serves as Secretary, and is also a member of Homer Lodge No. 199.  He is a member the Scottish Rite Valley of Danville, the York Rite Bodies of Champaign/Urbana (IL), the Ansar Shrine (IL), Eastern Illinois Council No. 356 Allied Masonic Degrees, Charter President of the Illini High Twelve in Champaign-Urbana (IL), and a Fellow of the Missouri Lodge of Research.  He was recently awarded the 2014 Illinois Secretary of the Year Award by the Illinois Masonic Secretaries Association.  You can contact him at: webmaster@toddcreason.org


  1. BINGO!!!! You hit the nail squarely on the head. I've been saying, no, I've been screaming this for a LONG time. I'm fortunate that I have a T.O. Lodge in my town that I CAN get Masonic Education.
    Preach on my Brother, preach on!
    Jon Greene
    Tulsa, OK

  2. Excellent ideas! Hand clapping from here!!!

  3. Another part of the puzzle is the insistence that brothers join the progressive leadership line almost immediately after being raised. Not all are called to leadership. Not all want to be in the line, or have the time to dedicate to doing it right. The members of the leadership line shouldn't be relied upon to do everything for the Lodge. Make the assignment of duties more collaborative. All members can do something beneficial for the lodge, even if it's a little thing.

  4. Fantastic article and great suggestions that I will pass on to the current leadership in my lodge and if not acted upon I will seek to implement when it is my time to occupy the Oriental chair. Also Kudos to the Photographer!

  5. I'd like to thank everyone for the overwhelmingly positive comments on this piece. Obviously, I think it's an important subject. I removed a few comments from here because they didn't have anything to do with the article, and the back and forth became argumentative, and that's not what we do here. This article is about change, and the difficulty with change is gettting people to see differing points of view.